Insurance companies generally do not remove lawsuits to federal court because they believe it will make them easier to lose. I know because, early in my career, I represented insurers in first-party property insurance disputes. We often preferred federal court. We knew its procedures, and some opposing attorneys spent considerably less time there. Moving the case could give us a practical advantage. We also wanted to avoid what lawyers call “hometown cooking.”

Paul Butler and I once tried a case in Jasper, Florida, where the judge, opposing counsel, bailiff, policyholder, and jury foreperson all attended the same church. The church was right next to the courthouse. As visiting insurance defense lawyers, we found this very concerning.  We sent a spy to the Sunday service just to make certain the case did not come up during or after the preacher’s sermon.

We prevailed because the facts were impossible to ignore, and Paul was brilliant in his closing argument, putting all the facts together. That part of the story matters because those shared connections did not establish unfairness or predict the verdict. Nevertheless, I have never forgotten that church. If you want to understand why an out-of-town defendant might prefer a forum with a jury drawn from a broader area, that experience provides a memorable example.

The procedural advantages can be even more consequential than concerns about local familiarity. Lawyers advising insurance companies have explained the attraction themselves. In Litigating the Declaratory Judgment Action, 1 attorneys Jamie W. Dittert and E. Hank Jones identify potential federal court advantages, including “a better summary judgment standard, more favorable precedent regarding the scope of discovery.” They also discuss case progression and the broader geographic jury pool.

The word “better” deserves attention. In that discussion, it describes a perceived advantage for the insurer’s litigation position. A lawyer evaluating where to litigate is considering how the available procedures may help the client win.

Insurance law professor Christopher C. French states the conventional strategy plainly in Forum Shopping Covid-19 Business Interruption Insurance Claims: “[I]nsurers prefer to litigate in federal court, and they should remove state court cases to federal court whenever possible.” 2

His discussion concerns insurance coverage litigation and explains the perceived advantages insurance companies think favor them litigating in federal court. Those advantages include judges, juries, and opportunities to resolve cases favorably before trial.

For readers who do not spend their days in courthouses, removal means that a defendant moves a lawsuit filed in state court into federal court under an applicable jurisdictional statute. In many property insurance disputes, the asserted basis is diversity jurisdiction, generally requiring complete diversity of citizenship and more than $75,000 in controversy, excluding interest and costs. Other requirements and limitations apply. The insurer cannot simply select federal court because it likes the address.

Once the case arrives, state substantive insurance law generally continues to govern the coverage dispute. The significant change is the federal procedural framework within which the parties must prove their positions.

My recent post, “Does a Mississippi Policyholder Need an Expert to Prove a Total Fire Loss,” illustrates how a possibly winning case can be lost because the policyholder attorney did not comply with strict federal procedures. The policyholder’s lawyers submitted 1,385 pages opposing summary judgment, but the courts found that they had not identified the particular pages supporting the disputed facts. A deposition submitted late without permission was also excluded from consideration. The appellate court additionally concluded that the properly identified evidence did not establish entitlement to additional benefits.

A mountain of evidence can look impressive. But Federal Rule 56 requires parties to support factual positions with citations to particular record materials. It permits the court to consider only the cited materials, although the court may examine other evidence. The rule also allows an opportunity to correct deficient factual support. Counsel should understand both the obligation to present the evidence properly and the available means of seeking relief when something goes wrong.

Expert disclosures create another important responsibility. Under Rule 37(c)(1), failing to disclose required information or identify a witness can prevent its use on a motion, at a hearing, or at trial unless the failure was substantially justified or harmless. A strong opinion from a qualified expert may accomplish very little if counsel has failed to satisfy the applicable disclosure requirements.

With all these procedural landmines, this is where federal litigation experience matters. When I represented insurers, familiarity with federal practice was one reason we welcomed the forum. A lawyer who regularly practices there understands that preparing the witnesses, meeting the disclosure deadlines, and organizing the summary judgment record are essential parts of developing the case.

There is empirical research supporting the importance of forum selection. Kevin Clermont and Theodore Eisenberg’s 1998 Cornell Law Review article, “Do Case Outcomes Really Reveal Anything About the Legal System? Win Rates and Removal Jurisdiction,” reported plaintiff win rates of 71% in diversity cases originally filed in federal court but only 34% when removed to federal court. 3

For policyholders, the practical lesson is that when considering the lawyers who will be retained, you must consider federal litigation experience when selecting that counsel. Ask who will handle the case, their experience in federal court, how the necessary experts will be prepared, and how the team will satisfy the court’s procedural requirements. A lawyer’s ability to explain coverage is important. So is the ability to put the evidence before the court in a form the court can consider. Those are two different things, and both are needed to win.

The bottom line is that the insurer has considered why it wants to be in federal court. The policyholder’s lawyer should be equally deliberate about how to succeed there.

Thought For The Day

“One thing they should recognize is that the federal system can get ahead of a lawyer.”

— Bruce Berman


1 Ernest H. Jones II, Jamie Wilhite Dittert. Litigating the Declaratory Judgment Action. In-House Defense Quarterly (2015).

2 Christopher C. French. Forum Shopping COVID-19 Business Interruption Insurance Claims. 2020 U. Ill. L. Rev. Online 187.

3 Clermont, Kevin M. and Eisenberg, Theodore. Do Case Outcomes Really Reveal Anything About the Legal System? Win Rates and Removal Jurisdiction. 83 Cornell L. Rev. 581 (1997-1998).