Imagine completing an appraisal, obtaining an award signed by a court-appointed umpire and your appraiser, and then receiving a check for substantially less than the award. You read the insurer’s accompanying letter to find out why. The insurance company says it retains the right to deny portions of the claim for coverage reasons. Fair enough. But which portions? Under which policy provisions? And how did those provisions produce the amount of the check?

Those questions are at the heart of a pending lawsuit involving AA Alpine Storage in Shreveport, Louisiana, and Ascot Specialty Insurance Company. 1 The case reflects a trend that I am seeing much more often following appraisal awards. The trend is that finishing the appraisal does not necessarily result in finishing the claim. Appraisal is merely the first step. The parties then litigate alleged coverage issues or the appraisal process.

The dispute arose from a May 22, 2024, hail claim. Alpine invoked appraisal, each side selected an appraiser, and the appraisers could not agree on an umpire. Ascot filed a declaratory judgment action, and Alpine moved for an umpire’s appointment. The judge selected Steve Schmitt to serve in that role.

The appointment order addressed another important issue. Ascot sought a ruling concerning the panel’s authority to examine damage that Ascot disputed was caused by a covered cause of loss. Alpine opposed limiting the appraisal to portions of the property Ascot was willing to include. The court declined to restrict the professionals’ work in advance, explaining that it expected them to assess the time and cause of relevant damage and provide sufficient detail to allow disputed coverage issues to be evaluated.

That approach makes practical sense to me. An insurance company should not be able to decide the scope of an appraisal simply by declaring that the disputed damage presents a coverage question. Determining what happened to a roof, what work is needed, and what that work costs often involves overlapping questions. Let the professionals examine the damage and perform their work.

The court did not rule that every item examined by the panel was covered. The policy expressly preserved Ascot’s right to deny the claim after appraisal. The appointment order allowed the appraisal to proceed, but did not decide the insurer’s ultimate payment obligation. Insurers are more frequently examining the appraisal awards and questioning specific issues through subsequent litigation.

According to Alpine’s recent November 20 motion, Schmitt and Alpine’s appraiser signed an award fixing the building loss at $2,350,557.36 replacement cost value and $1,891,036.38 actual cash value. The policy provided that agreement by any two panel members would be binding. Ascot’s appraiser did not have to sign for that contractual requirement to be satisfied.

Ascot’s November 3rd post-appraisal letter tendered an additional $519,326.65. The letter identified deductions for nonrecoverable depreciation, the deductible, and a prior payment. It also stated that Ascot retained the right to deny the remaining claim for “reasons unrelated to the amount,” giving as an example portions of the loss not covered under the policy.

Here is where I started looking for the explanation. The letter did not identify the particular uncovered components, quote the provision excluding them, or explain how the coverage position translated into the amount withheld. It referred generally to specific policy provisions without actually identifying a specific exclusion or coverage limitation supporting the unpaid balance. This denial letter fails to explain the facts and applicable coverage language that leads to the refusal to pay more money. In my opinion, such a letter is not a proper “good faith” denial because it fails to say why.

A reservation of rights tells the policyholder that the insurance company intends to preserve its options. It does not necessarily tell the policyholder why the check is short. The missing explanation is the connection between the damaged property, the policy language, and the dollars withheld.

The payment calculation raises another question. Adding Ascot’s stated deductions back to its new payment produces a starting figure of $826,772.17. The letter does not explain where that figure came from or reconcile it with the appraisal award. Alpine contends that Ascot paid according to its own appraiser’s estimate rather than the panel’s determination. That contention needs to be evaluated against the estimates, the award, and the actual coverage positions. The letter alone leaves the reader guessing.

To be clear, an appraisal award does not always equal the check. Deductibles and prior payments must be credited. Some depreciation may be recoverable only after repairs, while an endorsement may make other depreciation nonrecoverable. Limits and exclusions may also affect the amount payable. Those are legitimate matters to examine. But naming the categories of possible deductions is only the beginning. The insurer should explain which ones apply and show its work.

Alpine’s motion seeks approximately $1.25 million in additional actual cash value benefits after its stated deductions and credits. It also seeks a declaration concerning recoverable depreciation payable upon satisfaction of the policy’s repair requirements. Those are requests in a pending motion, not amounts the court has adjudged payable. Ascot’s response may identify policy language and evidence that its post-appraisal letter does not explain.

Earlier correspondence also matters. Alpine’s memorandum describes pre-appraisal disputes involving allegedly cosmetic roof damage and HVAC units. Those communications may provide context missing from the November letter. It would be premature to conclude that Ascot has never explained any coverage position. Still, once an appraisal is completed, an explanation reconciling the award with the payment would help everyone understand precisely what remains disputed.

For public adjusters and policyholders, the practical lesson is to ask for these reconciliations in writing if the insurer does not provide them. Which appraised components remain unpaid? Which policy provisions is the insurer relying upon to change the payment obligation? What facts support applying those provisions? How much is withheld for each reason? Those questions turn the phrase “coverage issues” into positions that can be evaluated, discussed, and, if necessary, decided by a court.

I would also distinguish a genuine coverage position from an attempt to repeat the valuation dispute. If the argument is that the panel’s price was too high or that the insurer’s appraiser had a better estimate, that raises a different issue from an exclusion applicable to identified damage. The label attached to the disagreement should not substitute for examining what the disagreement actually concerns.

We do not yet know how the court will resolve Alpine’s motion. What we can say is that appraisal should move a claim toward resolution. If coverage questions remain, identify them and explain them. A policyholder who has completed the appraisal process should be able to understand how the insurance company got from the award to the check.

For readers, I will follow this case in the future to see if there are other lessons to be learned.

Thought For The Day

“Most people eat to live; in New Orleans we live to eat.”

 — Ella Brennan


1 AA Alpine Storage v. Aspen Specialty Ins. Co., No. 5:26-CV-00758 (W.D. La.).