A claim can remain open while the courthouse door closes. Years of adjustment and litigation ended without a determination of how much the insurer actually owed for the disputed damage. One lesson from a recent federal opinion about proofs of loss and statute of limitations is never to reuse a notary signature.
In my recent post, A Late Proof of Loss Should Not End a Promptly Reported Insurance Claim, I questioned a ruling that prevented homeowners from pursuing additional actual cash value benefits even though the insurer’s own witness testified that the late proof had not affected its investigation or adjustment. I believe that testimony deserved considerable weight. But I also emphasized the practical lesson: Read the policy, calendar the deadlines, and submit a properly executed proof of loss. Tower Crossing Condominium Association v. Affiliated FM Insurance Company 1 provides another reason to take that advice seriously.
Tower Crossing managed a condominium complex in Glenview, Illinois. After an alleged July 2019 storm loss, the association and Affiliated FM spent approximately two years investigating and discussing the claim. The policy required a signed, sworn proof of loss and generally required suit within two years of the loss. The insurer agreed to extend the suit deadline through October 2, 2021.
On September 30, the association’s president signed and swore a proof of loss before a notary, reflecting approximately $2.95 million in replacement costs. Before that document was submitted, another board member with construction experience questioned the figures. The estimate was revised to approximately $4.34 million. According to the association, its president understood and approved the revision and authorized use of his earlier signature page.
That is where the trouble began. Instead of having the revised proof separately executed under oath, the earlier signature and notary page was attached to the new document. The association submitted that version on October 1, one day before the extended suit deadline.
Affiliated FM later rejected the proof because it disagreed with the claimed scope of damage. The association maintained that the insurer continued to consider the claim open and eventually paid approximately $194,000 after the lawsuit was filed. The association sued on November 19, believing that submitting the proof had stopped the limitations clock.
The Seventh Circuit Court of Appeals held that it had not. Under Illinois’s tolling statute, the contractual suit period is suspended when proof of loss is filed “in whatever form is required by the policy.” Here, the policy required a sworn statement. The president had sworn to the earlier valuation, but no new oath addressed the revised document. Transferring the signature page did not transfer the oath. The court affirmed summary judgment for the insurer because the suit was untimely.
The association emphasized that Affiliated FM had investigated the property, obtained the information needed to evaluate the loss, and determined that some payment was owed. The association also pointed out that the insurer initially rejected the proof over the scope of damage without identifying an execution defect. If the investigation had already accomplished its purpose, why should this mistake eliminate the opportunity to prove that more money was owed?
That concern resembles the one I raised in the Iowa post. Proof-of-loss requirements should serve a practical purpose in adjusting claims. Courts should examine carefully whether noncompliance impaired that purpose before allowing paid-for insurance protection to become unenforceable.
Still, the execution problem in Tower Crossing deserves to be taken seriously. A notarized signature page is not a reusable attachment. The relevant oath concerns the statement presented on that occasion. Permission to use a signature on a revised document may show that the signer adopted the revision, but adoption and an oath are different acts.
The association argued that a notary merely verifies a signature rather than the truth of the document’s contents. That argument missed an important distinction. A notary does not investigate roof damage or certify that an estimate is correct. But a notary administering an oath records that the signer formally swore to the statement. The certificate here referred to that sworn act. A later authorization to move the page did not establish that another oath occurred.
The appellate court also made a qualification worth remembering. It did not hold that notarization is the exclusive way to satisfy every policy requiring a sworn proof. It required an oath and left unresolved whether an appropriately worded statutory declaration could satisfy this policy. The practical course is to use a method that clearly satisfies the policy and governing law, rather than leave that question for an expensive appeal.
The most consequential part of the decision concerns substantial compliance. The court distinguished between satisfying a condition of coverage and satisfying the requirements for statutory tolling. Substantial compliance might answer the first question, it explained, without answering the second. Providing the insurer equivalent information did not substitute for submitting the sworn proof required to stop the clock.
It means an argument that the insurer had everything needed to adjust the claim may fail to preserve the time to sue. The Iowa case involved enforcement of policy conditions and prejudice. Tower Crossing involved the separate requirements for tolling a contractual limitations period. The same appeal to fairness can encounter very different legal rules.
I understand the court’s reasoning on this record. I remain concerned about a result that prevents a determination of the disputed benefits after a lengthy adjustment. But identifying a harsh result does not make the execution shortcut sound practice. This was an avoidable dispute over whether the final document had actually been sworn to.
Nor should the decision be described as a finding that the association committed insurance fraud. Affiliated FM used strong language about the document in its brief. The appellate court did not need to find intentional deception or decide that the revised estimate was false. Its ruling rested on the missing oath and the expired suit deadline.
For public adjusters and policyholders, the immediate lesson is straightforward. When material figures change before submission, have the insured review the final document and execute it properly under oath. Preserve the complete executed version, its attachments, and evidence of delivery. A properly executed proof that never reaches the insurer cannot accomplish a requirement that it be filed.
The equally important lesson is to maintain separate calendars for proof-of-loss obligations and suit deadlines. An extension of one should never be assumed to extend the other. Continued negotiations, an open claim file, or an invitation to provide more information should not be treated as an agreement extending the time to sue. Obtain any needed extension expressly and in writing before the deadline expires.
I will continue questioning technical forfeitures where an insurer had a fair opportunity to investigate and evaluate the loss. At the same time, I want policyholders and the professionals helping them to avoid becoming the next test case. A fresh oath and careful attention to the calendar are far less expensive than an appeal about why neither should have mattered.
Thought for the Day
“A little Neglect may breed great Mischief.”
—Benjamin Franklin
1 Tower Crossing Condominium Ass’n v. Affiliated FM Ins. Co., No. 25-3167, — F.4th —, 2026 WL 3561390 (7th Cir. Nov. 19, 2026). See Tower Crossing initial brief and Affiliated FM answer brief.



