Florida Reducing Hurricane Exposure

A year after the Florida Legislature and Governor Crist were duped by the insurance industry, legislation aimed at lowering the financial catastrophe of a major hurricane has been introduced to correct last year's mistake.  See HB 983.  Last fall, I spoke with Alex Sink regarding her concern that the collapsing bond markets could make it difficult for Florida to quickly raise money to pay for Catastrophe Fund obligations in the event of a hurricane.  Given the decrease in statewide tax revenues and the ever increasing credit strains caused in part by the sub-prime mortgage crisis, she has acted very prudently by supporting this legislation.  Obviously, if the state is picking up less of the insurance payments caused by a natural catastrophe, the insurance industry is picking up more.  Rates have to go up.  The question is:  How much?  The second question in an election year is:  If they go up a lot, are voters going to retaliate at the polls this fall? Of course, the State has an "out":  Citizens Property Insurance Corporations.  Citizens is a governmental entity "competing" against private insurers.  If it continues to charge lower rates, many policyholders and voters will be spared the increase.  Indeed, if the rates are limited to a 2 percent increase as reported in the Palm Beach Post, voter dissatisfaction probably won't materialize.  Nevertheless, the action by Sink and the Legislature was a step in the right direction.  We were a Katrina away from a major financial catastrophe, and this is a prudent step in the right direction.

The U.S. House Gets Its Turn with Big Insurance

Last week the Florida Senate grilled insurance executives regarding promised rate reductions that never materialized.  The news reports unanimously found that the insurance executives failed to fully and honestly answer questions put to them by the Senators ("In Insurance Talks, Beware The Jabberwock"; "Allstate Defends Rising Rates"; "Frustration at Insurance Rate Hearing"; "Keep the grill fired up for insurance companies").  This week, the U.S. House of Representatives Financial Services Subcommittee on Oversight and Investigations follows this inquiry.  Unless something drastic happens, the result is going to be the same---a lot of ducking of completely honest answers.  Florida legislators are not used to this treatment from corporate citizens and they know something needs to be done.

Continue Reading...

Allstate Testifies Today

Allstate Insurance Companies are being called before the Florida Senate Select Committee to testify today and tomorrow regarding a number of issues, especially its rate filings.  I have publicy applauded this inquiry and those interested can read the Committee's filings on the internet. The issues are a little broader than just rates.  The letter to Allstate from Senators Atwater and Geller list claims history and profitability factoring.  I expect that the Core Claims Process Re-Design documents and processes will again be a matter of inquiry. The hearing should be interesting because something like this has never occurred.  Public inquiry with extensive press coverage regarding an insurance company's honesty of its operations is something that should have occurred long ago.